diff --git a/src/encounter/encounter_check.f90 b/src/encounter/encounter_check.f90
index bbfa98ba3..b125d0ff9 100644
--- a/src/encounter/encounter_check.f90
+++ b/src/encounter/encounter_check.f90
@@ -189,7 +189,7 @@ module subroutine encounter_check_all_plplm(param, nplm, nplt, xplm, vplm, xplt,
          call move_alloc(itmp, index1)
          allocate(itmp(nenc+plmplt_nenc))
          itmp(1:nenc) = index2(1:nenc)
-         itmp(nenc+1:nenc+plmplt_nenc) = plmplt_index2(1:plmplt_nenc)
+         itmp(nenc+1:nenc+plmplt_nenc) = plmplt_index2(1:plmplt_nenc) + nplm ! Be sure to shift these indices back to their natural range
          call move_alloc(itmp, index2)
          allocate(ltmp(nenc+plmplt_nenc))
          ltmp(1:nenc) = lvdotr(1:nenc)
@@ -517,9 +517,6 @@ subroutine encounter_check_all_sort_and_sweep_plplm(nplm, nplt, xplm, vplm, xplt
 
          call encounter_check_all(nenc, index1, index2, xplm, vplm, xplt, vplt, rencm, renct, dt, lencounter, lvdotr)
 
-         ! Shift the tiny body indices back to their natural range
-         index2(:) = index2(:) + nplm
-
          call encounter_check_reduce_broadphase(ntot, nenc, index1, index2, lencounter, lvdotr)
       end if
       return